Relational frame

The opposition frame

Relating stimuli as opposites along a shared dimension.

What it looks like

Opposition carries more information than distinction because it names the dimension. Hot and cold are not merely different; they sit at opposite ends of temperature.

This makes combinatorial entailment interesting. If A is the opposite of B and B is the opposite of C, then A and C are in coordination, because two reversals return you to where you started.

Worked example

A learner is taught that "hot" is the opposite of "cold", and that "cold" is the opposite of "warm-ish" in a training frame.

The derived relation between the first and third terms is one of sameness rather than opposition. Learners who have coordination and opposition both in repertoire produce this reliably, and probing it is a good test of whether the frame is genuinely established.

Try a sample

Three of the activity types a learner gets, including the opposition tries themselves. Pick a type and try it. No account needed. In RFT App, sets like this are built for a specific learner.

Match a picture to the one that goes with it.

  1. Find the picture that is the same as this one.

    A golden retriever sitting on a plain grey background

    • A tabby cat sitting on a plain grey background
    • A golden retriever sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue bus seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    Answer

    The answer is dog. The picture at the top is a dog, so the dog is the match. A cat and a bus are neither of them a dog.

    Try 1 of 2

  2. Find the picture that is the same as this one.

    A blue car seen from the front, on a plain grey background

    • A brown rabbit sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue truck seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    • A blue car seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    Answer

    The answer is car. The picture at the top is a car, so the car is the match. A rabbit and a truck are both the wrong object.

    Try 2 of 2

Tap all of the pictures that belong, and none that do not.

  1. Tap every animal.

    • A golden retriever sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue car seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    • A tabby cat sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue bus seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    • A brown rabbit sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue truck seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    Answer

    The answer is dog, cat, rabbit. A dog, a cat and a rabbit are all animals. A car, a bus and a truck are not animals.

    Try 1 of 2

  2. Tap every one with wheels.

    • A golden retriever sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue car seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    • A brown rabbit sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue truck seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    • A tabby cat sitting on a plain grey background
    • A blue bus seen from the front, on a plain grey background
    Answer

    The answer is car, truck, bus. A car, a truck and a bus all have wheels. A dog, a cat and a rabbit do not have wheels.

    Try 2 of 2

Three opposition tries, the way a learner sees them.

  1. What is the opposite of hot?

    • cold
    • sunny
    • tall
    Answer

    The answer is cold. Hot and cold sit at the two ends of temperature. Sunny and tall are not opposites of hot.

    Try 1 of 3

  2. What is the opposite of open?

    • tall
    • closed
    • loud
    Answer

    The answer is closed. Open and closed are the two ends of one dimension. Tall and loud are about something else.

    Try 2 of 3

  3. What is the opposite of up?

    • fast
    • round
    • down
    Answer

    The answer is down. Up and down are the two ends of one direction. Fast and round are not opposites of up.

    Try 3 of 3

Sets like this, for your learner

Jack drafts sets like this for your learner in seconds. You edit them and assign them.

Sign up coming soon

How to build an exercise for this frame

  1. Anchor the dimension

    Make the dimension explicit before training pairs. Opposition without a named dimension collapses into distinction.

  2. Train paired opposites

    Teach two or three opposite pairs to mastery within the same dimension, with error correction.

  3. Probe the double reversal

    Test whether two opposition steps yield coordination. This is the diagnostic probe for opposition specifically.

Common pitfalls

Mixing dimensions inside one exercise is the usual failure: pairing hot and cold with big and small in the same trial block gives the learner no stable dimension to frame along. The second pitfall is skipping the double-reversal probe, which is the only trial that distinguishes opposition from distinction.

Build a opposition exercise

Draft the trial structure in RFT App, then edit it into the program you actually want.

See how it works

Other relational frames

Common questions

What is an opposition frame?
A relational frame that relates stimuli as opposites along a shared dimension, such as hot and cold or fast and slow.
What happens when you combine two opposition relations?
They yield coordination. If A is the opposite of B and B is the opposite of C, then A and C are the same, because two reversals cancel.